Close

The answer to an ethics question sometimes becomes obvious when it is apparent that every argument on one side is either a logical fallacy, an unethical rationalization, or the application of an invalid ethics principle. Such is the case here, and thus I somewhat question the motives of the author of the post, Kelly Anders.

Wishful thinking, perhaps? Asking the question creates the illusion that there is a real ethics of dating a former student. I addressed this question a long time ago, in an early post here barely seen at the time but among the most frequently visited since. I wrote:. Dating a student is a professional breach of trust, ethics of dating a former student one that adversely effects the integrity of the entire educational institution….

A teacher always has superior power over any student by virtue of his or her position of authority, and it is an abuse of that power to use it to entice students into dates or bed….

Will the professor consciously or subconsciously be easier on the friends of his student lover if they are in his class? The ethics of dating a former student that the question can be asked shows that the situation should not occur where it can be asked. Students, all students, must be off-limits as romantic partners for professors and administrators in universities, regardless of what rules are in place.

Professors who date students risk their jobs because a student body is not their sexual smorgasbord, and it is a breach of trust and duty to treat it like one. Nor is anything I wrote then revolutionary or new. These are the realities of authority, professionalism, leadership and power.

The few replies to the ProfsBlawg post that attempt to justify or excuse this form of academic incest are typical: like all attempts to shrug off this conduct, most fall into one of the categories I laid out in the post:. Who cares about who dates whom? How often does this occur i. What actual harm comes from this activity? I know all the potential harms: grades, recommendations, etc. Anytime someone tries to regulate human instinct in this case, the most powerful instinctthe regulation is just nighty hot tits anybunny sex.

com, so why bother? Example: fight on the ice, get banned for life; screw a student, lose your tenure. Distorting the educational relationship is actual harm. Teachers using their classes like dating bars is actual harm. Then the commenter stops numbering, but keep pulling out rationalizations and over-generalizations.

Is this gut a law student or professor? The correct phrasing is. Source: ProfsBlawg. Among the inevitable consequences of moral relativism. I out-rank many ethics of dating a former student my professors in terms of age, life experience, and personal blood shed for this nation, but I show deference to them because of convention, and respect for the work it took to earn their position.

It seems to me that I would be justified in withholding this deference from anyone who is, for all intents and purposes, preying on their charges, and really so would anyone else. Fraternization between officers and enlisted personnel is harshly punished for the same reasons, among which is the erosion of command structure. Also, yuck! In Rostker v. Goldberg4 53 U. United StatesU. LevyU. Thus, military policies have been upheld in situations where comparable civilian policies would be struck down.

See e. RostkerU. WeinbergerU. I was with you every step of the way, Jack, until your last paragraph. I think you are reading too much into what I wrote. Because college faculty are loathe to talk to therapists, so they talk to each other. Scary, really. It seems this school did not in fact have a rule against such things, and all of his paramours were of legal age, but after a number of complaints from parents and other faculty about him the school decided it was necessary to do something.

Their solution was assigning him to teach only online classes, working from home, which presumably would curtail his student-dating habit. Perhaps they thought physically distancing his activities from the campus would be a sufficient remedy? Plus, my wife would have handed me my head…literally. Patience and forgiveness are not among her strong suits.

What about former students? And how about non-faculty interracial paar am fkk strand employees?

Or the immediate family of faculty, whereby the faculty would be a potential in-law? Or the immediate family of an administration member? Non-faculty professionals who belong to another organization that is nevertheless working closely with the university as part of a project for the current ethics of dating a former student When is a professor not a professor? When she is no longer employed at the institution?

A professor dating a student at another school is not a conflict and is as ethical as if the person was not a student at all. Dating an ex-student comes close to or crosses the ethics line. Are you waiting for them to graduate to ask them out? Are you sure? Yes, this is pretty much where I came out when I dealt with that issue in As such, it seems improper to me for any current student to date any professor, regardless of proximity. Does this make sense?

I would think, however, that Ick Factor and yes it is mild Ick Factor at work aside, there is a limit on the ban. Then does a time period apply? I think Ick Factor has alot to do with this. If we distill out all other ethical conundrums that may be influencing this — is the Student angling for some post-graduation recommendation?

The ick factor is definitely at work for me. It seems predatory. I guess that many of the teen-aged undergraduates and immature grad students immediately come to mind. I think I might object to it for the same reasons I object to them using their influence to push their politics. But ick factor is irrelevent for current students- that we know is already unethical. I addressing the question of if after graduation is the ban lifted?

Well, the ick factor is still there for me, but I suppose it would be hard to defend the position that dating between them when one ethics of dating a former student longer has ties to their former status is unethical. The ick factor also has to involve age. A forty-something teacher dating an 18 year-old high-school graduate or a ethics of dating a former student year-old college graduate just does not sit well with me.

Screwing around pun intended with a younger still-being-formed mind in order to make yourself feel younger to me is ick personified. For example, a 35 year old adjunct prof and a 20 year old student.

Would it be OK for them to date after 40 years had passed, and they were 75 and 60 respectively? Based on an actual case I know of, that one.

At my high school. One of those teachers had to get divorced to do it. Be grounds for a gunfight in mine. But I graduated from a high-school with a student graduating class.

Hill-Country Texas. You have to understand that schools have changed. The authoritarian model is no longer considered appropriate. Now, teachers are supposed to be friends with their students. So, you have new, 22 year old teachers who are encouraged to be friends with teenage students.

Relationships between teachers and students are now rampant. It seems like sleeping with students is part of the job ethics of dating a former student for the high school coaches. I have heard of students around here competing to see who can be the first to sleep with a new coach or teacher.

Someone I know had an affair with one of their high school students. The parents of the student were fine with it until the teacher decided not to divorce their spouse and marry the student.

I had completely forgotten about ethics of dating a former student silly romance comic books, Jack. Where did you did up that picture? Sure- these things happen and likely always will. Lots of unethical, immoral and downright grim things happen with depressing regularity tumblr nackt girl nackt nackte reife have since before recorded history.

To legitimize liaisons between them is dead wrong.


© 2020
battlestar galactica » On-line sex videos for real sex fans  arhicve